1925 Harry Horne Co. Animals and Birds (FC1) Non-Sport Forum

Anyone have a ready access to the full checklist of this unlisted set?

From PSA set registry [1] and pop report [2]. Set registry lists 70 as you mentioned in the title, but the pop report lists 76, so possible duplicates.

[1] https://www.psacard.com/psasetregistry/non-sports/company-sets/1925-harry-horne-co-animals-birds-fc1/alltimeset/287061
[2] https://www.psacard.com/pop/non-sport-cards/1925/fc1-harry-horne-co-animals/114316

John Bell's Canadian Non-Sorts Catalog has the set as complete at 70. There are some back variations so that may account for the discrepency.

His set name is 1925 Harry Horne Co. Animals and Birds (FC1)

Sorry, no checkists in his book.

Back of the card says 70 in the series. I will try to build a checklist from your links. The card numbers are letters and there are some with the same letter.  Hope this does not pose a problem.

Bell has this a NNO set. 

The letter is part of the redemption/contest.

Here is a link for good visuals for confirmation of names. Unfortunately Phil only has about half on his site. 

https://www.openbinders.com/fc1-harry-horne-animals-1925/?sort=newest&page=1

Bruno and I just had a phone chat about this set, and other things too.

We could not come to a complete agreement on the numbering for this checkist. 

I feel the large lettering is just part of the contest described on the back. Thus a NNO set.

Bruno's point is there is presidence in a baseball redemption insert set that uses letters in this manner, both contest and numbering.   We couldn't remember which.  As well, a point was made that the prominence of the letter can be construed as the number.

See the PSA and Openbinders links for reference and visuals..

Thoughts so this checklist can be added.?

I would say put the redemption letter in the Note2 field and list these as NNO.

If there is a baseball set that is listed improperly, it's not a reason to do the same with other sets.

Agree. Contest cards are specifically for a contest and they have no repeated letters.  These aren't specifically contest cards. They are subject cards with a contest in addition to the subject description.  The letters have nothing to do with the card's subject.  Basically they're not a card number, they're a contest letter.

Here's a letter contest card set:

https://www.tcdb.com/Checklist.cfm/sid/101328/1992-Ultimate-WLAF---Giveaway-Game-Cards

All done including VAR. https://www.tcdb.com/Checklist.cfm/sid/346396/1925-Harry-Horne-Co.-Animals-and-Birds-(FC1). Over half were visually confirmed. The remainder were from the other websites.