2011 Magic the Gathering Judge Gift Promos Gaming Forum

Was going through all the Magic cards, when I noticed something odd. JGP 2011 #9, Wolf.

Now, all JGPs from 2004 to 2011 used the DCI symbol, as seen here on JGP 2009 #4, Survival of the Fittest. However, this card does not. As well as that, it looks the exact same as the Innistrad Token #12, Wolf.

Could you tell which one was the promo? Me neither. I even hashed it to MD5, and the hashes were the exact same. 37C62AB47A2083BB0EFAC2599C00666D. You can try it yourself if you want to.

Once I noticed that they were the same, I looked on mtg.gamepedia.com, my go-to resource for MTG information. I went to their page on Judge Gift Promos, scrolled down to 2011 - and bam, the Wolf token wasn't there. 

Anyway, what do y'all think of this? Yay its a card or nay we should remove it from our records?

It is listed here:

https://scryfall.com/sets/g11

but not here:

https://mtg.gamepedia.com/Judge_Gift

and looking at scans of a couple of the other cards shows they are numbered x/8. I'll look into it more after work, but I'm leaning towards removal.

Still no definitive answer, though it's looking less likely to be real. I'm finding more sites that don't list it than ones that do; further, only Scryfall and Aetherhub have images and I agree that those are no different from the regular Innistrad card. Fwiw, Beckett is in the yes camp:

https://www.beckett.com/search/?set_id=16938989&result_type=59

Okay, think I finallyhave the full story on this one. It is a different card, but it is not a Judge Gift Promo. As listed at: 

https://www.ccghouse.com/catalog/magic_singles-promotional_cards-promo_tokens/token__wolf_innistrad_prerelease__judge/98880

• This token was given out to Innistrad Prerelease participants that showed interest in the Judge Program. This token has 2 versions, the difference being information and picture on the back.

My judge contact has confirmed this information, and suggests listing it as an additional pre-release promo in the Innistrad set. I was unable to get the different back image to link directly in a useable form, but it should be visible here: 

https://www.google.com/search?q=Token+-+Wolf+(Innistrad+Prerelease+-+Judge)&sxsrf=ACYBGNTAi9nfjXU4bFxJ4bt4fRGSbnJgEw:1570556930806&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiI79a_nI3lAhVuUN8KHRIpDHkQ_AUIEygC&biw=1440&bih=753#imgrc=I2Ryzgw1vjDirM:

Thanks