C2Cigars is the winner! It is indeed from the 1997 Fleer Sports Illustrated set, not the 1999 Fleer Sports Illustrated set, which only has 1 autographed card and not Mays. It is the 1999 Sports Illustrated Greats of the Game issue that has the Mays auto. As he pointed out it does have the embossed authenticity stamp and it was SN250 on the back as stated in the title, and as it should be (sometimes you find these serial numbered to other numbers, these were reissued in later Fleer products). Fortunately for me, I knew what it was when I bought it - this was one of the 2 autos I was missing to the set, and had some Christmas money to splurge on it. But just an example of these great authentication services that seem worthless when things like this get by them. If they can’t get this right, why should I trust them to verify if a personally signed card is real?
C2Cigars wrote:
So much wrong with the listing. That's the 1997 card pictured; doesn't match the listing title. Not a single item in the specifics is correct. Looks like the autograph has an embossed authenticity.