General Forum

You whiffed on my absolute favorite Pacific because they did so many interesting things with cards way back when. but based on your list of producers

Topps 

Donruss (slight edge over Upper Deck because of some of the sets like preferred)

Upper Deck

Fleer ( The worst on any list because of some of the most gawdawful border colors ever especially the bright yellow borders on the 1991 baseball)

Score if included would be second to topps

Not trying to hijack but what did you all like better the dream team or diamond kings?

topps

doneruss

fleer

upper deck

Let's UPDATE our tally, what we got so far: using a scale of 1-5, I used 5 to be fair to Score voters

Topps = 151

UD = 95

Fleer = 90

Donruss = 82

Score = 31 ( included their votes here] These represent writeins

Honorable mention by popularity: OPC, Star, Post, Bowman, Hoops, Kellogs, Pacific and Press Pass.

and Panini

Of course our astute members did mention certain qualifiers, and you can read them by going through the posts.

Keep ranking.....Thx , ~Bob~

Diamond Kings, when it was 1 person from each team.

I'm a Topps homer but if I'm honest, I'd have to say that Upper Deck produced better flagship products during that time period. If going off nostalgia, then I'd say Topps is number one...

1- Upper Deck

2- Topps

3- Fleer (just now starting to appreciate their flagship product)

4- Donruss