Buy/Sell/Trade Forum

So I added a price on a item. Actually several different to be honest for multiple cards. There was one that I listed that sold for a super high price on eBay. Now a reviewer said the item was not really sold. I looked it up and it did not say redacted or anything.

The only thing  eBay page said was user relisted item or selling a similar one. It does not mean it did not sell one. It was a 90's card so people could have a few to many copies of them. 

So my ability to help with pricing needs to be reviewed by others now. How long will this last? 

Also why is this thought to be bad?  I own several of the same card. I can see the seller selling multiple of a card in many transactions. You dont want to show you have alot of inventory to a buyer, it might not make it as special. So what am I missing here?

Eventually once many successful prices have been added by you, it will let you do it yourself. I just don't know how many...

So I still don't see anything wrong with the one I actually  listed.  It says seller is selling item again or a similar one. So ... how is that wrong it does not show it is retracted on eBay so it appears somebody paid way to much for a card but that is my thought. 

Is there a certain rule on this? 

I mean if I sold a item for a high amount. I might just try to see if lightning strikes twice ??

Seen multiple listings of many different items on e-bay, which range from way less manufacturer price,

to obscenely overpriced.....

Just the way internet sellers are.....

If someone overpays for a card and then the seller quickly relists the same card it could be a scam where the buyer is known by the seller and they fraudulently make that first "sale" to try and encourage other people to make a real purchase at an artificially inflated price. 

Plus you have to have a good acceptance rate. If you are not adding good prices. It doesn't matter how many you add.

If ebay says that seller relisted it is likely the original buyer never paid so they simply relisted it. This has happened to me several times.

So, What is the card in question? A 1990 Donruss for $12,000 where the exact card is available by the hundreds for 99 cents (or less) everywhere else.

I am sure you are referring to your submission of the 1991 Donruss Mark McGwire #56 (INC. var) [1] that was "sold" for $123 [2]. I was one of many people who denied the price submission.

A couple of flags:
- The buyer has 0 feedback, indicating they are a new account that does not have any previous transactions (sales/purchases). Therefore, they are likely shilling/trolling/etc. the buyer who has listed a junk wax era card for a great price. eBay will still mark this as a "sold/completed" item, even if the buyer does not pay (eBay please change this!).
- The seller is almost a five-year-old account, but no sales, only purchases for which they have gained feedback
- The price for such a card is outrageous, look at any other active or sold listings... $0.50, $0.99, $1.25, etc.
- The fact that the "sold" pages says the seller has "relisted this item or one like this", typically indicates they have relisted to same item.
- The card has been relisted multiple times with the same price and even higher, no listing has received a bid [3,4,5].
- Card is still active [6]

[1] https://www.tcdb.com/ViewCard.cfm/sid/152/cid/71507/1991-Donruss-56-Mark-McGwire

[2] https://www.ebay.com/itm/125240302263

[3] https://www.ebay.com/itm/125249604465

[4] https://www.ebay.com/itm/125262352301

[5] https://www.ebay.com/itm/125275783012

[6] https://www.ebay.com/itm/125288483401

With this info revealed all I can say is to apply "Common Sense" when submitting prices.