For what its worth i assumed that the trade was completed and then changed. Ie...accepting a trade, then weeks later getting a msg that they didn't have the cards in the trade (I had already mailed) I've encountered weird trading experiences but does that make them a bad trader??? Weeks to reply, no reply at all or cards have gone "missing" before trade is accepted even a card shipped in pwe,(no protection at all but card was fine) Although I felt like giving negative feedback...is it warranted? Out nothing and/or receiving cards in good condition. I remind myself that it may not be the same priority as I have assigned it.
My personal fav, was receiving a lopsided trade proposal, in countering I evened out the value based on bin pricing and explained it, I then recieved a msg saying that thier 1 card was worth more than all of mine....because "i said so!" then claimed i was "scamming" him......where I exercised the option to simply walk away. Is he a bad trader or delusional? I wouldn't bother looking at another trade from him, but does that mean he's trading in bad faith or a seemingly overused term these days...a scammer?
I'm not a veteran trader by any definition but it seems like a lot of people define a fair trade as heavily lopsided in thier favor. Not talking about the majority in here, but people in general.