1998 Collector's Edge Supreme Season Review Football Forum

Does anyone know why some rookies in this set have only a gold foil version and some only have a holofoil version?  In looking up information, I have only found 8 examples where a card has both:

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,=1998+supreme+season+review+61e,ot,i20

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,i20,=1998+supreme+season+review+74b - have to look at different images in this one

http://www.comc.com/Cards/Football/1998/Collectors_Edge_Supreme_Season_Review_Holofoil/101A/Randy_Moss/6041080

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,=1998+supreme+season+review+109c,ot,i20

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,=1998+supreme+season+review+134a,ot,i20

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,=1998+supreme+season+review+165a,ot,i20

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,=1998+supreme+season+review+165c,ot,i20

http://www.comc.com/Cards,sc,i20,=1998+supreme+season+review+172a

I would appreciate any information people might have

I put this set together when it came out. The rookies were a mail in promotion. Team cards were inserted into packs. You mailed in the redemption card with a buck and would receive back a card with that teams first round pick, if the team had more than one first round pick you would receive a card for eah of their first round picks.  It was stated that they would be limited to 500 of each. Season in Review was released before the draft so the rookies were not printed at the time of the release. I opened a whole case, so  I mailed in most of the teams cards within the first month. When those cards came back shortly after the draft, they were all the silver holo foil. As I later got ahold of the rest of the redemption cards, I mailed them in and they came with the gold foil. I called Edge to find out why. They told me the silver holo foil cards were the first 500 printed and the actual rookies. They received many more redemption cards than they had anticipated. So they then printed up the gold foil cards because they could not mail back cash, which is how most people paid, so it was actually cheaper than sending a $1 check back to everyone after the first 500. They went out of business shortly after so there has always been confusion. I know first hand the Silver holo foil are the actual rookies and the gold foil are the parrallel. Not the other way around. So the holo foils are very underpriced because there are only 500 of each. Manning and Moss, with only 500 made, are a steal. I have tried to explain this to many web sites and price lists, but it is hard to prove since Edge is out of business. 

As I was looking at a trade with this set I had an issue.

This posting answered a couple of my questions.  Still have a couple questions.

I have 2 rookies in this set.  128a & 172a  Scott Frost & Ahman Green.    I have both Holofoils,  a Gold and Silver of Scott Frost.

The Holofoils show the year 98 under the Edge Logo  Appears all of the holofoil is marked 98 what I can see

The Gold & Silver shows the year 99 under the Edge Logo   Can not tell if all the Gold are marked as 99

It also appears that some of the images are not correct.  With my eyes I'm not sure so I would not do an IR.

I have no problem leaving the Gold (RC) in the base and Holofoils as parallel set   Just wondering if it should be notes so how.

Then where does my Silver card go??   Is it a misprint??