Site Forum

I've been working on DOB's from the To Do's. I found one that all I could find is a birth year of 1881. Is there a way to input just a birth year?

Currently in the New Feature tracker here:

https://www.tcdb.com/FeatureTracker.cfm?MODE=VIEW&ID=3&PageIndex=2

I've ran across a few with no associated cards. Should those be deleted?

Like this one here

Yes, please.

another names question here.  I've noticed many of the trainers and other mom players have a (TR) after their name. Should all the non players have such indicator in their name tag? I figure you can make a new tag with the indicator. Update the name tags on the cards and the delete the old name tag. 

also how do you remove or report incorrect external links on players? I've found a number of them that have links to the wrong baseball reference profile.

They only should have the (TR) if the name is the same as a player (it's a differentiator - there's only one Barney Nugent in baseball as far as I know, and he was a trainer - no need for the TR after his name - he's the only one). No need for the extra work.

However, if there is a name that needs a differentiator added (or the spelling of the name on the PID needs to be changed or to answer your other question, to get incorrect external links removed) - go into edit info, and then there will be the "See any inaccuracies" link - use that - it goes to Admin (bypasses the IR system, since he's the only one who can make those edits) and enter the instructions for Admin.

First....Awesome work!!! It is the little house cleaning things like you are doing that make this site awesome! I think the "behind the scenes" housework is among the most important things that TCDB members who want to contribute can do. Additionaly, you're seeking guidance, clarification, and confirmation in the forums. That is also awesome! Too much well intentioned work has to be undone because a member with high initiative didn't take a moment to do that.

Since you mentioned creating a "name tag" (PID) and adding a descriptor in the differention field ("DIFF").......

First we should clarify terms just to make sure we are talking about the same thing. You're saying "name tag"; the official TCDB term Is PID (Person Identification). At least, it is if we are talking about the same thing; which I'm pretty sure we are.

I always add a descriptor in the "DIFF" field when I "Add a name", even if there isn't a currently conflicting name in the database. I have added a lot of names for vintage non-sport cards and several times I found myself adding different people with the same names. This happens a lot with royalty and politicians. Once you add the name and create the PID it is very difficult to go back and add "DIFF" descriptor -even if it would be useful. It is always useful when there are two of the same name. So why not add it right away, just in case someone with the same name ever gets added to the database?

For people I use the birthdate in this format (b. 1969).

I'm currently doing a lot of work in the gaming category. For that I use the title of the game, Pokemon, MtG, etc.. (Not that you or many others care about the Gaming Category. lol)

I don't do much work in sports, so I'm not going to comment on formating for those categories. But for politicians, royalty, actors, etc.; the positions people hold in life change. One thing that doesn't is their birthdate. For a little  while I used things like "actress" or "singer". I think it is pretty obvious that those descriptors fall short, so over time I've settled on birthdate.

Just sharing a TTP (Tactic, Technique or Procedure). I'm an old soldier and that's what soldiers do. No insult or offensive intended.

Thanks for the advice, Chad!

Yes, it's members, like Jeremy, who go unheralded. And the fact that he's doing this all the right way (asking questions when unsure instead of plowing through and potentially doing things that will need to be undone) is awesome. Hopefully, the questions asked here (and answered here) are helpful to other members as well.

For the record on technical naming conventions? So the programmer in me would consider PID to be the unique identifier. The actual number. I was using "name tag" to refer to what would display in the Missing DOB list. Which would be the "Name Field" & "(Diff Field)" associated with the PID.

I do see some usefulness having the (TR) display in the Missing DOB list. I know to just skip over those, and move on to one I'll have a better chance of finding. I can probably find something doing a deep dive on some vital records searches, but I would rather knock out the easy ones first before I go full on history detective on them.  

I've got into the Name Checking too. I've had decent luck figuring out some of the old vintage cards through baseball reference and sabr. I'm talking the 1900-1920's stuff. I've got some linked up to existing PID's and added some new ones for the ones I've found good enough references for. Where are we at on making some educated leaps on the ones with just last names? For example I found a player name "Phoenix", there's a Bill Phoenix (just example may not have that first name right) with decent records for years prior to and after 1910, but nothing on baseball Reference for 1910. Very high likelihood the "Phoenix" in card is the Bill Phoenix with 1910 missing in his records. That couldn't have been a very common name in 1910. Were I working on genealogy, I would call that a match and roll with it. More common names are tougher. Do you make a PID for someone you only have a last name for? It's possible said player could have more than one card with only last name known that could be linked. I've only been making ones for players I can at least get a initial on, and have reference for. There are some the have references with only last names.  I'm kinda curious to check old census records for guys listing baseball as an occupation. 
 

enough rambling. Thoughts?

Non baseball people

this one is for a frisbee dog and his trainer. One of those weird A&G cards. 

is he supposed to have a baseball PID? Or should it be linked to him as a Misc Sports PID?