Site Forum

Like others said, definitely $1 card to save on taxes....

If buying any quantity from the same seller, $1 with separate shipping is always the better choice since most sellers give a big combined shipping discount.  Say you bought 10 cards.  In my choice it would be $10 plus maybe $3.50 for shipping.  In the "free" example, it would cost $20.

There is a relatively new real-life example of this concept to try for yourself.  Burbank just relisted all of their base commons at $1.69 with free shipping in eBay and raised the price of most other cards slightly.  Find several cards you want and compare the total cost against online sellers like Cards & Games, Triple Play, etc. that have similar inventory.  See what the difference in cost will be.

I like the poll feature overall.

it is fun to me to see what % of people answered same as I did

Mark

You all are making a lot of assumptions when answering this. Nowhere does it say it's a transaction on a site that collects sales tax or that it involves a seller that may give multiple card discounts - because it doesn't mention multiple cards - it only mentions 1 card for $1/$1 or $2/free, that's all. So, it's 1 card for $2 out of your pocket either way. Seriously, what difference does it make at that point? None.