General Forum

So back in August I received a 500 card order from COMC but it turned out to be 502 cards. I don't know if it is something they did on purpose or not but they sent me a J.J. Watt card and then they also sent me a Jamie Benn jersey card. I don't collect hockey or football and the order was 500 baseball cards for 2 teams. Have any of you ever experienced something like this?

I've never received 'extra' cards from Comc.  I just got an 850+ card order and it was perfect. I have received a couple of incorrect cards in the past, but those were a different variation of the card they should have sent. I've never received more cards than I ordered.

I have never received extra cards from COMC. Nor have I ever received an order with missing cards. On two occassions I ordered base cards and received parallel versions instead, and on two other occassions I ordered parallels and received the base cards instead. I wasn't bothered enough to complain in either case. (And really, who's going to ask if they can return a LeBron James SN25 "Holo Green" parallel because they really had their heart set on getting the $2.00 base version?)

Never received extra cards but I did receive a base of someone when the add said green parallel.  They didn't have the right card, admitted their mistake and gave me back my money. Out of 5 orders that was the only one not perfect. 

My experiences with COMC have all been positive and very similar to all the other reply's here. I've made 3 orders over the past year or so all at 200+ cards. All had cards spanning all sports, non-sport and gaming with parallels and what not, lots of room for possible errors, but out of everything I ordered only had 1 card incorrectly sent as a base when it should have been a parallel. Never had them short me cards or send extras though

I had one of the wrong parallels in one order and then another order had four of the saem card stuck together when I only ordered one. 

Interesting. It was surprising to me to receive those cards especially a jersey card, (it is game worn,) and then the J.J. Watt was also weird. I didn't pay for them they just showed up. Next thing you know I'll get a Babe Ruth auto or something. Only if...

Never got anything other than exactly what I ordered from COMC.  To be honest, I'd be surprised if they sent you extra intentionally. COMC is a consignment business, meaning they don't own the cards they're sending out...they're just storing, advertising, and processing the cards for sale while earning a commission.  If they send extra cards, they're giving away someone else's property.  It's likely going to come out of their pocket when someone buys that extra card and they can't find it. They're going to have to pay the seller and refund the money for the buyer.

In ten years of buying from them.  30 shipments  2,547 cards.   I have had a hand full of issues with the shipments.   I never have had them send me extra cards.   I did have cards returned that they did not support which I was not a wear they were going to do.  No e-mails just the cards showed up in my next shipment with a note.    One shipment missed a card.  All other issues were getting the base when I purchased a parallel.    They were all cheap cards under $2 so they refunded the money and I was allowed to keep the other cards.