General Forum

I pulled a Roger Clemens orange refractor with no S/N in an Allen & Ginter Chome box and I sent it back to Topps for replacement but realized recently that maybe I should have held on to it.  I returned it because I don't like Roger Clemens so I'd be happier with whatever comparable card they send me, but now I'm thinking that might have been dumb.  I can probably get in touch with them and make sure they don't replace it, but I really don't know what to do.   

Is a missing S/N on a nice card a valuable error?  

Thanks

Hmmm when faced with similar dilemma I kept the card.  I got a card from one of Topps Doctor Who releases which was actually double stamped with two different serial numbers.  Good luck either way with getting the card back or the replacement!

This is just my opinion but I think errors are more valuable when they're more blatantly obvious than just missing an SN.  It's still cool but if you're going purely for value I think you made the right choice by sending it back.