1993 GameDay McDonald's All Stars Football Forum

Don't want to file an IR if there was a previous concensus on this specific set, just not sure if it is listed correct?  Seems like it should be 29 separate sets. These were issued in perferated sheets, 6 cards to a sheet, 3 sheets to a "set".   There was an "All Stars" set of 18, numbered 1-18, and 28 team sets, with the cards for each set numbered 1-18, not 1-1 through 29-18 like they are numbered here.  

Also, the full sheets are listed as a separate set.  Is that correct, or should they be listed in "Inserts and related sets" (I know a full sheet isn't an insert, but could be a "related" set. The sheets were numbered A, B, and C in each set. Full sheets are here:

https://www.tradingcarddb.com/ViewSet.cfm/sid/73526/1993-McDonald'sGameDaySheets

From looking at the change log, the set pre-dates the individual set change logs, so I have no idea who added the checklist, but from the amount of edits, it was an absolute mess.

I agree with you with your suggestions. It actually wouldn't be ALL that hard to pull off (without Admin's assistance). And yes, if they were each issued in 3 6-panel sheets, those should be listed as the related set.

PM me, and maybe between you and me, we can pull this off correctly.

I'm just spitballing here as this would be different then what we do with the SI For Kids cards but are essentially the same concept.  Why not List all these cards in the related sets of the sheet panels?  Then you could have one for each team under related sets and the numbering could still be McD12 or whatever the card number is.  I might be explaining it too well, but by doing it the way I described, we could just have admin move all the scans to the new related sets and then delete this one.

Working with Dan on these.  Ufortunatly the sheet panels are named different depending on set, and the numbering starts over per team (Sheet A, B, and C), this is 29 separate sets...

(Accidentally referred to the sheets set listing with this message as opposed to the individual cards, but can someone look at the sheets and see if my point applies? Thanks.)

Agreed that they are all separate sets but don't necessarily agree that the card numbers for each should be A, B, C.

Each A sheet also has the card number 1 (of 3), while the Bs say 2 and the Cs say 3.

Should the number take precedence with the sheet letter in the notes?

The Sheets do say:

Sheet A

1 of 3

Shhet B

2 of 3

Sheet C

3 of 3

I will hold off on numbering them / adding checklists in the new sets until I get word from Dan/Admin on how they should be

I have moved this thread into the All-Star set because we would lose it if it stayed with the "master" set that will eventually be deleted.