I had forgotten that the '88 Dodgers had cut him late in the season, which really stunk since they went on to win the W.S., a career accomplishment that eluded Sutton. I looked up an article from the Oxnard Press-Courier (8/11/88) .. Dodgers said they cut him to make room for prospect Ramon Martinez, whose stats were no better than Sutton's at year-end. By any objective measurement, Sutton was pitching better than Fernando V., but a mob would have stormed the stadium had they cut Fernando instead.
Don is the classic case of a compiler or accumulator (according to critics) ... the description of players who have watered down the baseball HOF by playing forever. It's impossible keep out a 300+ game winner, but his career was strange because he was almost always was NOT the best pitcher on his teams. Look it up: Koufax, Drysdale, Singer, Osteen, Downing, Messersmith, Hooton, John and Sutcliffe all had better seasons at least once compared to Sutton during 1966-80, but only the first two are in the HOF. Even when he topped the NL in ERA in 1980, three teammates (Reuss, Welch and Hooton) had more wins.
I wonder whatever happened to all those scuffed Sutton balls Sparky Anderson was collecting ... Ebay?! How can anyone talk bad about '70s baseball?