Card Identification Forum

I do not see this listed. It was a mail in offer advertised on wax pack wrappers. It came with the pin punched through the card from Fleer as I pictured the front. Looking to add it as a related, should I just add/picture it as shipped with the pin through the card? Or?

Not listable. It wasn't included in packs and doesn't get graded. It'd be like adding a shirt or binder from the Topps Company Store.

But it is a card available as a mail in promotion. Like the Topps mail in only white thin paper checklists. The 1980's Topps  mail in cards. Probably more similar mail in cards too. I never felt the pin would be appropriate.

Pins are listable when they were made by card companies and available through card companies. 

Other collectibles that are inserted into packs or boxes of traditional trading cards are allowed to be listed in order to fully document the inserts that were included.

Other items made by card companies, sold via card retailers, and authenticated by card grading companies are also allowable.

Listing items created by third parties printed with the likeness of cards (like plates, coffee mugs, and T-shirts) goes beyond the scope of the site.

These were from a mail-in offer, like binders, shirts, baseballs, those weird Pinnacle display things, etc. If these were included in packs as an insert, then yes, we can list them, but that's not the case here. This is just a Fleer pin and wasn't authenticated by any of the main companies.

Ask Admin. You're wrong. Send a link to this thread. 

Even if not, the card it was attached to is listable. 

Sent and we'll see what he says

As rude as Billy was about this, I still have to agree with him on this one. The card belongs for sure and the pin should also be listed here. Ed, you need to stop reading the FAQ lines when there are blurs between them. What you typed before means that even mail-in CARDS aren't getting in the DB. Fleer had more mail-in cards and sets than anybody besides the Topps All-Star sets from the 1980's.

All this bickering about "is it allowed" is starting to get on my nerves and it's obvious that many other collectors just don't care any more. Activity on this site has dropped drastically, even though the population is up and IR's have skyrocketed. I'm personally sick of dealing with all the crap that has come from the minute differences in every single card that had over a million copies made and stupid requests for stuff that won't work on the site and...and... and...

It never ends........................................

Just enjoy the cards!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Type out multiple various reasons with supporting facts about why something should be done some way, get ignored or get it put the exact opposite way it should be just because I said it should be the other way. Straight to the point and get called rude. I can't win. There's reasons I was away from the site for most of last year...

There was also a football one released as well FYI :)