Site Forum

I think the OP and Budler are talking about two different things.  Budler, I think he's asking for a feature specific to your own collection.  Like, it would compare how you are doing with Lavonte David compared to Ndamukong Suh, by percentage not total, without regard to other members.  If I understood correctly. 

I think that idea would be very beneficial to members. I know that I would likely have fun with a stat like that. I know some players I have complete collections of and others that are far from finished.

Love this!  I was just looking at my Dodgers collection and was surprised to see I'm #1 John Roseboro collector.  That sent me down the rabbit hole of looking at different Dodgers players. Fun stuff!!!

um actually if i understand your ? correctly it does already exist . Go to your collection and go to where your top lists are then click on whoever you have the most of. If you click on the name  I.E. I collect Greg Maddux after clicking on his name from my collection it shows me where I am at in regards to total # of his cards and where I stack up against other collectors of his cards by total number.

Actually just checked it before it took me to comparison of other collections it did ALREADY show me total # of Maddux cards and # of ones I owned / also % I have.

But only for Maddux, correct? This thread is imagining a page that lists a whole bunch of your card totals / percentages for different players in one place. That way, you could see your number & percentage of Maddux cards versus Smoltz versus Glavin cards versus whoever else without having to click around to each person. That way, you could also see who your top guys were without having to check every single player in your collection.

Sorry   It is really 3 different things.

1.   listed in % of completion of cards of a player   Which we have but hard to compare

2.    listed by number of cards compared to other players in your collection  Rank in your collection   Which we have but hard to compare

3.    listed by number of cards compared to other members haves.   Ranking among other members  Which we have but hard to compare

What is wanted ??  (if I understand correctly) is to have an area(s) where all of your players are listed for the 3 things.  So we can compare easy.     So we do not have to go to each player to find the information just to one place (report).  As of now you can go to a player and see the % of haves and the ranking of that player to all other players you have.  Go down a ways on the page and you can see the way your collection of that player is to other members.

Doing this could be hard as things will chage every mintue.   So maybe it would have to be a report that people could run.  Like the trading report maybe only every week or so.  It could take a lot of time to run a report  if you had a lot of players.

I may be wrong with what OP wanted but I would be happy if it was done.  Just something fun and interesting knowing but no big deal.

Im glad to see that most of you guys like the idea :), most of you guys understand what im saying, the list would be similar to the one in stats of top player collections but would be % of collection done of the player instead of number of card collected of that player, my personal collection i have 240 or so wayne gretzky card, he is my top player collected but 240 compared to the thousands of cards he has to his name is only a very small percentage, some players i have 50 of their cards and they only have 75 cards to their names so those percentage would be way more, thats what id like to see the list of who percentage wise i have the closest to completion :)