Site Forum

I haven't seen anywhere that we have a TCDB card hall of fame. I think that it would be cool to have one on our website voted by members.

The idea I have is start on the First day of the year we have a week of suggesting cards to be inducted into the TCDB's card hall of fame. After the first week we vote on the top five cards for each sport. After the second week we would again vote on the top ten cards from the first vote. Everyone will vote for their top three cards. The top two cards will get into the TCDB card hall of fame. If another card gets over 80% of votes it will also get into the TCDB hall of fame. In the case of a tie of three or more cards for the top vote getters and they are not over 80% of the votes everyone will get two votes and the top two will get in. 

So the timeline will look like this:

January 1st a forum starts with nominations for cards from each sport + gaming opens and members will comment links to cards they think deserve to be in the TCDB card Hall of Fame.

January 8th I will open a list with each sports nomination included and members will vote on their top five cards from each sport + gaming.

January 15th The list will be trimmed down to the top 10 vote getters and members will vote on their top three cards

January 25th Voting closes and ties are voted on if needed.

February 1st The list for TCDB card Hall of fame is announced

This is my thought for a TCDB card hall of fame. Please discuss bellow and let me know your thoughts. I will facilitate everything to the best of my abilities. 

Great idea, I think it would be a lot of fun!

Create a forum asking for everybody's favorite card of all time now. That is how we should start itis off for the first ever ballot.

Or even just start with some famous ones like the Honus Wagner or Billy Ripken F Face card.

That is the plan on January 1st. Just want every ones thoughts and opinion first.

I like this idea. Can it be registered into that forum that has all the site change ideas?

What a great idea! I'm looking forward to seeing some of the cards that pop up.

Funny you posted this, I had a similar idea after reading the MLB Hall of Fame Class of '22 forum posting.

Considering I also thought of something similar, I think it's a great idea!

I nominate 1989 Upper Deck #1 Griffey for inclusion into the future TCDB Hall of Fame!

A unique twist might be that because it is specific to TCDB, the TCDB Hall of Fame must be cards that are owned by TCDB Members. If not then it is just another card ranking. Cards owned by TCDB members and scans of the actual card must be used.

That's a really cool idea! Can't wait to vote, and hear other people's opinions. Might not be the most valuable cards that get votes, which is part of what makes collecting fun.