Site Forum

Looking for guidance/opinions ... I was skimming over the 1971 OPC CFL set and noticed that a few of the cards are beat up, to say the least.  Also, the checklist is marked up.  The image quality of these cards is acceptable, but is there a demand or a need to replace the images of lousy condition cards?  I have this set ... haven't looked at it in ages, but as an example, I probably have a much better version of this card:

https://www.tcdb.com/ViewCard.cfm/sid/9500/cid/3414890/1971-O-Pee-Chee-CFL-85-Gary-Wood

If replacing the image is unnecessary, that's fine ... since it's not marked for replacement, I don't think I can do anything to it at this stage anyway.

You may submit an IR for image quality then submit a replacement image(s).

Not sure if you need a certain level in permissions but you can replace any image with a better scan without the IR process.  No need to remove points from another member who submitted an image of an older card.  This is different than when they are more recent sets where there is no reason to submit a poor condition card image (unless it is a rare card that unfortuantely got beat up).

Looks like level 7 permissions are needed for what Bruno suggested. 

Correction: If a card is tagged for replacement, the original submitter does not lose any points.

Only if images are removed will the submitter lose points for that.

Any checklist cards that have been marked in pen by someone need to be marked for replacement (Altered).