Update: So I decided to peel all my 1997-98 Finest cards and they do look much better. Here is my luck though, while I was pulling the film off one card it pulled a little hard at the end and right onto the back of the Jordan card I had stacked right next to it. When I pulled the bit of film off the back of the card it looks like it may have removed some coating or left some residue.
Maybe the card always looked like that, not really sure. But it kind of looks like a little rectangle that is lighter then the rest of the card when you hold it in the light at an angle.
Anyways, I also peeled a refractor I had from 1998-99 Finest and wow that card looks completely different when peeled. I have had that card for over 20 years and never really got a good look at it.