Buy/Sell/Trade Forum

I'm selling my dad's duplicates for him, so that he can complete some sets instead of having a couple thousand duplicates. I'm starting with 1972, because he has 1,100 dupes from that set (not a typo). I'm selling the high numbers and some of the stars individually, but I'm planning on selling various starter sets to move the commons. 

I don't have much experience with large vintage lots, so I'm wondering how I'd determine the prices. I'm thinking that maybe I'd add up the most valuable cards, and then do a set price for the rest of the cards. But I'm not sure what that price would be. Maybe 40-50 cents for VG-EX cards? That might be a little too high for selling a large lot (like 400 cards).

I'd appreciate any advice. Also, if anyone is interested in them, they are also available for trade (in return for vintage).

A good starting point may be to check eBay for prior sales...

What wbaker01 said, but if you're patient, you could try to sell them at the start for the price/card that you mentioned. If no one bites (whether it's due to price or postage), you can always relist with a lower price. Keep going until someone hopefully buys it from you. I will say that if you start low and hope for multiple bids you might be able to move the cards out faster if that interests you.

I'm interested in any Cardinals cards that I don't have yet. I'll trade for them or buy them. PM me or send a trade proposal.